We use cookies and other technologies for functionality, security, and to provide you with a personalized experience on our online services. By continuing to use our online services, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. For information on how to adjust your privacy settings, visit our Cookie Policy.
Dismiss
Home ON St. Catharines - Niagara Niagara-on-the-Lake Old Town
59 SHAKESPEARE Avenue
Directions Print
59 SHAKESPEARE Avenue $1,200,000
View from above of property with a pool
View of front facade featuring a gate, a wooden deck, a chimney, and a shingled roof
View of swimming pool featuring a fenced backyard and patio surround
Bird's eye view of a nearby body of water
Living area featuring light wood-style flooring, a glass covered fireplace, recessed lighting, and wood walls
Living room with light wood-style floors, a fireplace with flush hearth, and wood walls
Living area featuring light wood-style floors and a fireplace
Living area with a fireplace, light wood finished floors, wood walls, and recessed lighting
Living area with light wood-style floors and wood walls
Living room with light wood-type flooring
Living area featuring light wood-type flooring
Living area featuring light wood-style flooring and lofted ceiling
Dining area featuring lofted ceiling and light wood-type flooring
Dining area with light wood-style floors, a wainscoted wall, and vaulted ceiling
Dining room featuring light wood finished floors, a fireplace, and lofted ceiling
Dining space featuring light wood-style floors
Dining room featuring light wood finished floors, wainscoting, and plenty of natural light
Kitchen featuring gas stove, light wood-style floors, a kitchen island, and plenty of natural light
Kitchen with green cabinetry, stainless steel gas range oven, light wood-style flooring, and butcher block countertops
Kitchen with green cabinets, butcher block counters, stainless steel gas range oven, light wood-type flooring, and plenty of natural light
Kitchen featuring green cabinets, stainless steel appliances, light wood finished floors, and wood counters
Kitchen featuring green cabinets, stainless steel appliances, light wood-type flooring, and wooden counters
Staircase with stone finish floors and baseboards
Bedroom featuring light wood finished floors and vaulted ceiling
Bedroom with light wood-style flooring, multiple windows, and lofted ceiling
Bedroom with wood finished floors and lofted ceiling
Bedroom featuring light wood-type flooring, vaulted ceiling, and multiple closets
Bedroom featuring hardwood / wood-style flooring, two closets, and wood walls
Bedroom with light wood-style floors and recessed lighting
Bedroom with attic access and light wood finished floors
Full bath featuring vanity, a shower stall, and tile walls
Bathroom with vanity, tile walls, and wainscoting
Bedroom featuring wood finished floors
Bedroom with dark wood finished floors
View of floor plan / room layout
View of floor plan / room layout
View of floor plan / room layout
Wooden terrace with area for grilling, outdoor dining area, and a fenced backyard
View of swimming pool with a shed, a fenced backyard, and patio surround
10 hours ago
$1,200,000
Hide
Favourite

59 SHAKESPEARE Avenue
Niagara-on-the-Lake, Ontario L0S1J0

MLS® Number: 40808247
3 + 1
Bedrooms
2
Bathrooms
2100
Square Feet

Listing Description

Proven Turn-Key Airbnb Investment Fully furnished, professionally managed, and immediately revenue-ready: This 4-bed, pool-equipped gem has delivered consistent short-term rental income with minimal owner involvement. Approaching $200K gross revenue in 2025, consistent occupancy, consistent steady upward trend in revenue and ADR with direct booking upside, controlled costs, and turn-key readiness for cash-flowing retirement/investment use. Located in a premium tourist market, this property outperforms market medians thanks to central location, stylish boho-chic design, and private in-ground pool driving premium rates and 5-star reviews. Slide deck validation available, contact for details, calendars, and comps. Properties like this are a rare find. Key Recent Upgrades & Low-Maintenance Features (Turn-Key Ready) Major Systems: Roof (2014), furnace/components (2019/2023), electrical (2000), plumbing (2008), sump pump + battery backup (2023), new sewage line (2023), whole-home dehumidifier (2024). Exterior/Backyard: Full landscaping revamp (front + back/side), new gravel seating/dining areas, outdoor lighting, BBQ (2025), pool cover (2025), security cameras (2022). Pool: Saltwater system (professionally managed) Interior: Top-to-bottom repaint, kitchen renovation (new range, stove, sink, dishwasher 2025), refinished hardwood, modernized design, all-new furnishings/décor/artwork. This is a plug-and-play profitable asset: Solid Cap Rates and Proven cash flow from day one, strong appreciation potential in one of Ontario's most desirable wine-country/tourist enclaves (walk to Queen Street, Shaw Theatre, wineries, Lake Ontario; 20 min to Falls, 90 min to Toronto). Perfect for Toronto retirees or U.S. snowbirds, enjoy peak seasons personally, then let it generate income during off-periods or travel. High guest appeal, and direct booking upside make it a resilient, high-yield retirement investment. (HST will apply) (70215834)

Location Description

Lakeshore Road, left on Shakespeare

Property Summary

Property Type
Single Family
Building Type
House
Square Footage
2100 sqft
Subdivision Name
101 - Town
Title
Freehold
Land Size
under 1/2 acre
Built in
1940
Annual Property Taxes
$4,534.10
Total Parking Spaces
4
Time on REALTOR.ca
10 hours

Building

Bedrooms
Above Grade
3
Below Grade
1
Bathrooms
Total
2
Interior Features
Appliances Included
Dishwasher, Dryer, Washer, Microwave Built-in, Gas stove(s)
Basement Type
Partial (Unfinished)
Building Features
Features
Conservation/green belt, Crushed stone driveway, Sump Pump, Private Yard
Foundation Type
Block
Style
Detached
Structures
Shed
Total Units
0
Heating & Cooling
Cooling
Central air conditioning
Fireplace
1
Fireplace Type
Other - See remarks (Electric)
Heating Type
Forced air, (Natural gas)
Utilities
Utility Type
Electricity (Available), Natural Gas (Available)
Utility Sewer
Municipal sewage system
Water
Municipal water
Exterior Features
Exterior Finish
Vinyl siding
Pool Type
Inground pool
Neighbourhood Features
Community Features
Quiet Area
Amenities Nearby
Airport, Beach, Golf Nearby, Marina, Park, Place of Worship, Schools
Parking
Total Parking Spaces
4

Measurements

Square Footage
2100 sqft
Above Grade Finished
2100 sqft
Source: Owner
Total Unfinished
465 sqft

Rooms

MetricImperial
Main level
3pc Bathroom
Den
Bedroom
Foyer
Living room
Dining room
Eat in kitchen
Second level
Bedroom
Third level
3pc Bathroom
Primary Bedroom
Lower level
Bedroom

Land

Lot Features
Frontage
58 ft
Land Depth
127 ft
Other Property Information
Access
Highway access, Highway Nearby
Zoning Description
R1
Are you interested in touring this listing?
Request a showing

Similar Listings

Melissa Vass Scott